Talk:Hotel Guest Lists United States

From FamilySearch Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search

This page needs a few more pieces of information.

When I tracked down Alabama I found only one name for the whole state. Further, at least for Alabama it was not a hotel register, but really a newspapaer announcement that someone was at a hotel.

This immediately brings this page into question from two sides. First, is it significant enough to be included in Alabama for one name? Second, are we guilty of bait and switch by suggesting this is a hotel register when it is really a newspaper announcement?

It would help to list the cities and hotels included under each state. Please indicate which are indexed. Please give the dates covered by each register. Please estimate and list how many names are found in each register.

We need enough details to know if this source is worth clicking. At the moment it is deceptive rather than helpful. DiltsGD 14:53, 21 September 2010 (UTC)